Research Paper

Assessment of the Effects of Septic Tanks on The Quality of Hand Dug-wells in Logo I And II, Makurdi, Benue State Nigeria

Volume 2, Issue 3 - November 2026

Assessment of the Effects of Septic Tanks on The Quality of Hand Dug-wells in Logo I And II, Makurdi, Benue State Nigeria

Paper ID: CRSIJ26000541

Author(s): BURBWA Fanen, Prof. T. N. Tee, Dr. J. A. Jande

Category: Environment

Research Area: Water Quality Assesement

Pages: 122-138

Published Date: 16-11-2026

Volume/Issue: Volume 2 Issue 3 November-2026

ISSN (Online): 3108-1584

CC BY 4.0 This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Abstract

This study assessed the effects of septic tanks on the physicochemical and bacteriological quality of water from hand-dug wells in Logo I and Logo II. A total of 20 wells (10 per ward) were purposively sampled during the dry season (February). On-site and laboratory analyses followed standard methods (APHA, 2017; WHO, 2017), covering parameters such as pH, electrical conductivity (EC), total dissolved solids (TDS), dissolved oxygen (DO), turbidity, ammonia (NH₃), hardness, sodium (Na), potassium (K), and bacteriological indicators (Escherichia coli, Salmonella sp., and Total Bacterial Plate Count – TBPC). Data were analysed using descriptive statistics, two-way ANOVA, Mann–Whitney U test, and the Entropy-Weighted Water Quality Index (EWQI). Samples were categorized by gradient positions (above and below 30 m from septic tanks) to examine proximity influences. Results showed that all physicochemical parameters exhibited slight variations across locations and gradient positions, with near-neutral pH values ranging from 6.58 ± 0.14 to 7.02 ± 0.09. TDS ranged between 572 ± 69.9 mg/L and 664 ± 67.8 mg/L, while other parameters (DO, temperature, EC, turbidity, NH₃, hardness, Na, and K) remained relatively stable. Two-way ANOVA indicated no statistically significant effects of location, gradient (30 m), or their interaction on any physicochemical parameter (p > 0.05). The EWQI classified water quality as “good” for both gradient positions (71.84 above and 66.92 below), with turbidity and TDS contributing most to the index. In contrast, bacteriological analysis revealed notable spatial differences. E. coli and Salmonella sp. were completely absent in all Logo I samples, indicating good bacteriological quality. However, E. coli was detected in 40% and Salmonella sp. in 10% of Logo II samples. Mean TBPC was significantly higher in Logo II (31.13 CFU/100 mL) than in Logo I (5.50 CFU/100 mL) (p = 0.044, Mann–Whitney U test). Both locations exceeded the WHO guideline of zero detectable bacteria in potable water. The findings highlight a clear disconnect between physicochemical parameters (which suggested acceptable quality) and bacteriological indicators (which revealed localized fecal contamination risks, particularly in Logo II). No strong gradient effect was observed at the 30 m threshold during dry-season sampling, likely due to aquifer buffering, lateral flow, and low recharge conditions. This study underscores the vulnerability of shallow hand-dug wells to microbial contamination from onsite sanitation systems in densely settled peri-urban areas with permeable soils. While the water may appear suitable based on physicochemical and EWQI assessments alone, bacteriological contamination poses potential public health risks, including waterborne diseases. It is recommended that local authorities enforce a minimum separation distance of 30 meters between hand-dug wells and septic tanks (with preference for up-gradient siting), promote standard watertight septic designs with regular maintenance, mandate household water treatment (e.g., boiling or chlorination), and establish routine seasonal monitoring programs. Expanded municipal water supply and integration of hydrogeological considerations into land-use planning are also essential for long-term protection of groundwater resources in Makurdi.

Keywords

Septic tanks, Hand-dug wells, Groundwater quality, physicochemical parameters, Bacteriological contamination, fecal contamination, Water Quality Index (EWQI), Microbial pollution, Peri-urban groundwater, Makurdi

Citations

BURBWA Fanen, Prof. T. N. Tee, Dr. J. A. Jande, "Assessment of the Effects of Septic Tanks on The Quality of Hand Dug-wells in Logo I And II, Makurdi, Benue State Nigeria", Cosmo Research & Science International Journal, vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 122-138, Nov. 2026.

BURBWA Fanen, Prof. T. N. Tee, Dr. J. A. Jande (2026). Assessment of the Effects of Septic Tanks on The Quality of Hand Dug-wells in Logo I And II, Makurdi, Benue State Nigeria. Cosmo Research & Science International Journal, 2(3), 122-138.

BURBWA Fanen, Prof. T. N. Tee, Dr. J. A. Jande. "Assessment of the Effects of Septic Tanks on The Quality of Hand Dug-wells in Logo I And II, Makurdi, Benue State Nigeria." Cosmo Research & Science International Journal, vol. 2, no. 3, November 2026, pp. 122-138.

BibTeX
                @article{CRSIJ26000541,
                  author = {BURBWA Fanen, Prof. T. N. Tee, Dr. J. A. Jande},
                  title = {Assessment of the Effects of Septic Tanks on The Quality of Hand Dug-wells in Logo I And II, Makurdi, Benue State Nigeria},
                  journal = {Cosmo Research and Science International Journal},
                  year = {2026},
                  volume = {2},
                  number = {3},
                  pages = {122-138},
                  issn = {3108-1584},
                  url = {https://cosmorsij.com/published/CRSIJ26000541.pdf},
                  abstract = {This study assessed the effects of septic tanks on the physicochemical and bacteriological quality of water from hand-dug wells in Logo I and Logo II. A total of 20 wells (10 per ward) were purposively sampled during the dry season (February). On-site and laboratory analyses followed standard methods (APHA, 2017; WHO, 2017), covering parameters such as pH, electrical conductivity (EC), total dissolved solids (TDS), dissolved oxygen (DO), turbidity, ammonia (NH₃), hardness, sodium (Na), potassium (K), and bacteriological indicators (Escherichia coli, Salmonella sp., and Total Bacterial Plate Count – TBPC). Data were analysed using descriptive statistics, two-way ANOVA, Mann–Whitney U test, and the Entropy-Weighted Water Quality Index (EWQI). Samples were categorized by gradient positions (above and below 30 m from septic tanks) to examine proximity influences. Results showed that all physicochemical parameters exhibited slight variations across locations and gradient positions, with near-neutral pH values ranging from 6.58 ± 0.14 to 7.02 ± 0.09. TDS ranged between 572 ± 69.9 mg/L and 664 ± 67.8 mg/L, while other parameters (DO, temperature, EC, turbidity, NH₃, hardness, Na, and K) remained relatively stable. Two-way ANOVA indicated no statistically significant effects of location, gradient (30 m), or their interaction on any physicochemical parameter (p > 0.05). The EWQI classified water quality as “good” for both gradient positions (71.84 above and 66.92 below), with turbidity and TDS contributing most to the index. In contrast, bacteriological analysis revealed notable spatial differences. E. coli and Salmonella sp. were completely absent in all Logo I samples, indicating good bacteriological quality. However, E. coli was detected in 40% and Salmonella sp. in 10% of Logo II samples. Mean TBPC was significantly higher in Logo II (31.13 CFU/100 mL) than in Logo I (5.50 CFU/100 mL) (p = 0.044, Mann–Whitney U test). Both locations exceeded the WHO guideline of zero detectable bacteria in potable water. The findings highlight a clear disconnect between physicochemical parameters (which suggested acceptable quality) and bacteriological indicators (which revealed localized fecal contamination risks, particularly in Logo II). No strong gradient effect was observed at the 30 m threshold during dry-season sampling, likely due to aquifer buffering, lateral flow, and low recharge conditions. This study underscores the vulnerability of shallow hand-dug wells to microbial contamination from onsite sanitation systems in densely settled peri-urban areas with permeable soils. While the water may appear suitable based on physicochemical and EWQI assessments alone, bacteriological contamination poses potential public health risks, including waterborne diseases. It is recommended that local authorities enforce a minimum separation distance of 30 meters between hand-dug wells and septic tanks (with preference for up-gradient siting), promote standard watertight septic designs with regular maintenance, mandate household water treatment (e.g., boiling or chlorination), and establish routine seasonal monitoring programs. Expanded municipal water supply and integration of hydrogeological considerations into land-use planning are also essential for long-term protection of groundwater resources in Makurdi.},
                  keywords = {Septic tanks, Hand-dug wells, Groundwater quality, physicochemical parameters, Bacteriological contamination, fecal contamination, Water Quality Index (EWQI), Microbial pollution, Peri-urban groundwater, Makurdi},
                  month = {November}
        }      

Download Paper

Download Full PDF